The Sicilian Butcher - Peoria

Food was delicious and the service was even better. Cheyenne was super attentive and sweet. 10/10 on everything.

Stopped by for a quick drink tonight. The bartender Mike was all-around fantastic and made me one of the best drinks "job well done"! If you like great service, ask for Mike. If you like coconut drinks, get the job well done.

This was our first time at this place after 3 failed attempts to find a good happy hour in the area today. Its happy hour every day here and we had a great time! The food was great. Our bartender/server,Cheyenne was awesome and helped us make decisions with a few items on the menu. We will definitely be back for a seat at the bar.

Food- Delicious
Atmosphere- Delightful
Bartenders- Cheyenne & Mike; talented mixologists!

We went with another couple, and had an enjoyable experience. We started with the bruschetta board, which has some excellent choices, but sharing one order with four people wasn't quite enough for everyone.
We loved the pasta with Tony's Meatballs and vodka sauce, but wished they had an option for angel hair pasta. My wife and I split the entree, and there was plenty for both of us. We would have liked a bit more vodka sauce, but it wasn't a big deal.
The beer selection was a bit limited, especially for light beers, but they did carry Peroni's, which I have loved ever since I first tried it in Tuscany.
We also thought the menu was a bit limited, but we still enjoyed our evening.

I had food delivered but it was very it was very good & tasty. When we were looking truffle meatballs- that sold.
Then looking further on the menu, I saw lentil soup & I have been boy.
I was thinking of making some at home-

Great location in Peoria!
5 months ago I mistakenly reviewed Sicilian Butcher under Sicilian Baker since they are a two in one location, restaurant and dessert shop at one location.
We came a second time as we're from San Diego and consistency is on point! Definitely one of our favorite eateries.
We ordered:
Sicilian New York Strip
Gnocchi Mac & cheese
Margarita pizza
Octopus & calamari
Lemon meringue mini pie
Assorted cookies
ALL AMAZING!

We took my parents, my aunt, uncle and kids to the SB on Thursday evening. This is hands down one of our absolute favorite family restaurants. The manager does a fabulous job of checking in with his customers to make sure they are having a lovely experience. The kids loved watching the homemade pasta being made on the side of the restaurant. The decor is lovely, the service was spot-on and the food was UNBELIEVABLE! Everyone is our group just loved what we had that evening: a sausage pizza & a number of different craft meatball combos with the delicious, fresh, homemade pasta!!

Can't wait to go back!

Service was fantastic. Love the atmosphere. Got the meatball Ferris wheel, the flavors were good but it was a bit cold. Also for the margarita pizza which exceeded my expectations and was delicious.

My friend raved about this spot and I was so excited when she told me we were having dinner here. The music, the food, and the service did not disappoint! Our table shared the Sicilian Style bruschetta taster board, I personally loved the sweet and creamy Fig Jam + Ricotta + Agave + Pear one. For my main, I thoroughly enjoyed my Pesto Mafalde with Uncle Arthur's Sausage Meatballs. The meatballs were perfectly seasoned and cooked, the pasta al dente and coated in all that pesto and cheesy goodness. Plus it was a large portion, perfect for leftovers. I also had a bite of their 'Lobster Tail' dessert from their bakery which was so delicious! A light nutella mousse/whip filled crispy pastry. The perfect "not too sweet" to end the night. I'm excited for my leftovers tomorrow as well as my next trip back!